Anthony is a 2010 graduate of Bethel Park high school. He played three for years under coach Jim Ryder and one year for coach Steve Bucci from 2007-10. During his senior season he batted .500 while leading WPIAL Quad A in home runs and RBI en route to all-WPIAL and all-section honors. His 7 home runs during his senior season were, at the time, a record at Bethel Park.
Upon graduating, Anthony committed to La Roche College playing under coach Chase Rowe from 2011-14. While playing at La Roche, Anthony held down starting spots in the outfield and catcher each of his 4 years. During his years there the Redhawks went on to win their first and second conference championships and played in the D3 regionals.
For summer ball, Anthony played for the Pittsburgh Pandas in the tri-state collegiate league under coach Frank Gilbert.
Anthony has been a JV head coach and Varsity hitting coach for the South Park Eagles in 2016 and 2017.